Michael Lewis and Tom Lee held court docket at a podcast taping in New York Metropolis on Tuesday, speaking to SoFi’s head of funding technique, Liz Thomas, for her present, The Necessary Half. In a wide-ranging dialog that lined, amongst different issues, Lee’s ideas on flash-frozen meals know-how and Michael Lewis’s dinner with OpenAI CEO Sam Altman with reference to Sam Bankman-Fried, the 2 towering figures in finance debated whether or not the present selloff in software program shares was turning into one thing extra severe. They have been grim, but humorous.
The duo dissected a market outlined by excessive volatility, through which software program shares are “down a ton” and synthetic intelligence threatens to wipe out whole industries. However probably the most arresting second got here when Lewis, writer of The Huge Brief, shared a morbid statistic about who really makes cash in these environments.
“Did you know Fidelity published a report about the best-performing retail accounts of Fidelity?” Lewis requested the viewers. “And it was all customers who died.” (Lewis was referring to a well-known 2014 examine that discovered, in actual fact, the best-returning portfolios have been left alone, whether or not owing to loss of life or absent-mindedness.)
A number of moments later, Lee cited analysis about how 40,000 shares have both gone public or been spun off since 1974, of which 90% fell by greater than 50%, the overwhelming majority going to zero: “So in other words, the majority of stocks basically went to zero.”
FOMO or loss of life?
The anecdote underscored a central theme of the night: In a market whipped right into a frenzy by a concern of lacking out (FOMO) and algorithmic buying and selling, doing nothing is commonly the superior technique.
“The message is not: die,” Lewis clarified dryly. “Don’t over trade.”
Lee, head of analysis at Fundstrat, supported this view with information from his personal agency. He famous that whereas institutional traders have shrunk their time horizons to mere days—or in some circumstances maintain shares for “like 40 seconds”—retail traders are literally “getting it right” as a result of they’re working with “permanent capital.” Or being actually lifeless, they’re unable to withdraw their capital from the market. Not like hedge funds that churn positions based mostly on every day P&L, retail traders sit on their property.
“As you know,” Lee advised the group, showing to discuss with high-frequency buying and selling patterns, as lined by Lewis’s ebook Flash Boys, “the average stock is held for like 40 seconds. So most [of] these large hedge funds … one second or five seconds is considered a long holding period. So a lot of funds are literally just churning through stocks.” (Asset administration govt Barry Ritholtz has taken problem with estimates of this nature, arguing they apply solely to high-frequency merchants and should not consultant of most inventory market exercise.)
Lee famous Thomas made level in her immediate, nevertheless.
“There is something that’s different this year. All of a sudden, a lot of stocks and industries are starting to have shrinkage,” Lee stated. “So the software industry, for instance, is seeing shrinking demand and a repricing of their service, and there’s now many research reports pointing out that agentic AI products or AI products are starting to replace traditional software.”
It’s quite a lot of shrinkage, too. Bloomberg calculated an iShares ETF monitoring software program shares has bled roughly $1 trillion over the previous seven buying and selling days.
Lee stated he considered this as proof of AI’s productiveness and a long-term optimistic, reasoning that much less is being spent on software program as a result of AI is fulfilling this operate as a substitute; there are additionally fewer tech workers now than in 2022, when ChatGPT was launched.
Lewis, although, stated he noticed echoes of the dotcom bubble. He warned traders are as soon as once more “conflating the technology with corporate profits,” assuming that simply because AI is transformative, it’s going to inevitably result in inventory market windfalls.
“It may, in fact, be a machine for reducing corporate profits,” Lewis argued, suggesting lots of the present high-fliers may finally come “crashing down.”
The dialog veered into existential dangers for different asset courses as effectively, portray an image through which even “safe” property may theoretically go to zero. Lee urged Bitcoin could possibly be rendered out of date by quantum computing and even by AI itself—if AI decides to run its personal “language of validation” and bypass human crypto chains totally. Even gold, a $35 trillion asset class by Lee’s calculation, isn’t protected from devaluation.
“There’s a million times more gold underground than above ground today,” Lee stated, reasoning that if it will get too costly, the Magnificent Seven will simply get into the gold mining enterprise, “because you might as well just dig for gold.”
Given the discuss of bubbles and potential asset collapse, Lewis revealed he has moved right into a defensive crouch—particularly, the “Armageddon trade.”
“When I own [gold], I think I’m long fear,” Lewis admitted, revealing he has a place within the metallic, which he didn’t advise any listeners to comply with him in buying. “I don’t see any reason not to be scared. And I think fear is not a bad thing to be long right now.”
For the residing traders within the room, the takeaway was a paradox: The market is harmful; know-how is cannibalizing earnings; and one of the best ways to outlive could be to emulate the lifeless—the one dependable capital is everlasting capital.
