After I first noticed Elon Musk write that he would “probably end up paying over $500B in taxes, inclusive of death,” I needed to learn it twice simply to ensure he hadn’t added an additional zero as a joke.
He posted that line on X (previously Twitter) whereas reposting a clip the place he known as himself “the largest individual taxpayer in history” and mentioned he had already paid greater than $10 billion in tax, joking that the IRS at the least owed him a little bit trophy for the trouble.
He made the declare as his wealth surged to about $852 billion after a merger of SpaceX and his AI enterprise xAI right into a mixed firm valued round $1.25 trillion, Instances of India reported.
To me, that $500 billion quantity reads much less like a exact forecast and extra like a means of translating “I am the richest person on Earth” into the language of tax receipts.
He’s placing a price ticket on his relationship with the tax system over his life and at his demise, and that alone is a helpful framing if you happen to’re making an attempt to know what rising wealth and altering tax coverage truly imply in greenback phrases.
Elon Musk might find yourself paying as much as $500 billion in taxes.
Picture by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI on Getty Pictures
Andreessen’s response turned the dial to 11
Musk’s projection was large, however Marc Andreessen’s response is what actually blew the dialog into “billionaire math” territory for me.
“Elon is being characteristically modest. The true number will likely be closer to $5 trillion. Maybe higher,” the Andreessen Horowitz cofounder wrote on X.
Associated: Elon Musk says cease retirement saving: Consultants name it ‘nonsense’
Andreessen was arguing that Musk’s private taxes alone might finally attain into the trillions when you think about a long time of positive factors and remaining property taxes, earlier than you even rely what his firms, staff, and traders can pay, Chinese language outlet Sina Finance’s evaluation highlighted.
I don’t learn Andreessen’s quantity as a spreadsheet outcome; it appears extra like a provocation that forces you to think about taxes on the dimensions of nationwide budgets moderately than particular person fortunes.
The thought of a lifetime tax invoice “exceeding $500 billion” is unprecedented, and Musk has not printed any mannequin explaining how he will get to that whole, MEXC famous.
After I take into consideration these two numbers facet by facet, $500 billion and $5 trillion, what jumps out isn’t which one is “right,” however how rapidly taxes can compound after you have a trillion-dollar stability sheet that largely lives in unstable inventory.
How billionaire taxes actually get that large
If you happen to strip away the social-media theatrics, the mechanics of how a tax invoice like this might accumulate are pretty simple, simply blown as much as an unfamiliar scale.
- First, there may be the half Musk has already lived by.
In 2021, he exercised an enormous set of Tesla choices and bought sufficient inventory to set off what information shops reminiscent of Bloomberg broadly reported as roughly an $11 billion federal earnings tax invoice, one of many largest single-year funds ever recorded.
- Then there may be all the things that occurs whereas Musk is alive and nonetheless controlling these firms.
After the SpaceX–xAI merger, the Instances of India reported that Musk held a few 43% stake within the mixed entity value roughly $542 billion, alongside an roughly 12% stake in Tesla and an enormous choices package deal that might add as much as $1 trillion extra if Tesla hits long-term targets.
- Each time he workouts choices or sells inventory, realized capital positive factors create taxable occasions, and people occasions get greater because the underlying shares admire.
On prime of that, Andreessen identified that there’s a parallel stream of company earnings, payroll, and different taxes paid by Musk’s firms and staff, saying these quantities might at the least match his private tax invoice over time.
The final piece is the phrase that caught my consideration: “inclusive of death.” That’s the place property tax and any future wealth or inheritance levies are available in.
Extra Private Finance:
- Why promoting a house to your youngster for a greenback can backfire
- Elon Musk says ‘universal high income’ is coming
- FTC, 21 states sue Uber over ‘shady’ subscription billing
A significant health-care union is pushing a proposed “Billionaire Tax Act” in California that may impose a one-time 5% tax on residents with internet value over about $1.1 billion, payable over 5 years on prime of current state and federal taxes, Bloomberg reported.
If one thing like that handed and was replicated, the property of somebody whose wealth finally reaches into the trillions might face a unprecedented remaining invoice, even earlier than counting federal property taxes and any charitable or different planning.
After I put all of that collectively in my very own head, I don’t want a exact mannequin to see how the tax meter can hold working: each main liquidity occasion, each coverage change, and finally the property itself provides one other large chunk to the overall.
Why Elon Musk’s tax invoice issues to you and me
I’m clearly not anticipating to pay something like Musk’s tax invoice, and also you most likely aren’t both, however I nonetheless assume this dialog is beneficial if you happen to make investments, run a enterprise, or simply care about how coverage shapes cash.
For one, it’s a reminder that concentrated fairness is each a wealth engine and a tax time bomb.
Musk has mentioned that his internet value is sort of fully tied up in his positions in Tesla and SpaceX, with little or no held in money, a sample Goelite and different shops have famous in protection of his fortune.
If you happen to maintain plenty of a single inventory, whether or not it’s your employer’s shares or a long-term winner in your portfolio, you’re coping with a smaller model of the identical math. The upper it goes, the larger your eventual tax hit if you happen to ever want or need to promote.
The distinction between us and Musk is scale, not the underlying guidelines.
Second, the Musk–Andreessen alternate places a human face on one thing that may in any other case really feel summary: coverage danger.
Rich residents might see an additional five-figure proportion of their internet value successfully booked as future tax over a five-year interval, on prime of all the things else, Bloomberg reported on the California billionaire tax proposal.
That may sound far-off if you happen to dwell in a distinct state or nation, however we’ve already seen repeated proposals for federal wealth taxes and better property taxes within the U.S., typically with specific references to folks like Musk within the political messaging.
Lastly, I feel there’s a private finance lesson right here that goes past politics.
If you happen to take a look at your individual long-term plan, you may select to be intentional about when and the way you set off taxes, whether or not which means spreading out inventory gross sales, utilizing tax-advantaged accounts, donating appreciated property, or planning how your property will likely be taxed.
Can anybody actually pay half a trillion in tax?
Here is the pure query I requested myself after sitting with these numbers: Is that this actual, or simply billionaire bravado?
If something, Musk’s “over $500B” line nudged me to take a look at my very own assumptions about future tax charges and coverage adjustments and to keep in mind that my spreadsheet is barely pretty much as good as the foundations it bakes in.
The mathematics he’s speaking about is simply compounding, focus, and taxes taken to an excessive, and those self same forces are quietly engaged on our personal stability sheets yearly, simply with fewer zeros.
Associated: OpenAI accuses Musk’s xAI of destroying proof in escalating lawsuit
