“I inherited a mess,” President Trump advised an viewers of supporters in Georgia final Thursday, referring to the U.S. economic system. The Democrats “caused the affordability problem, and we’ve solved it!” he bragged. Two days earlier on Fox Enterprise he had proclaimed an excellent grander achievement: “I think we have the greatest economy actually ever in history.”
When a president talks like that 37 weeks earlier than the mid-term elections, it means one factor: The economic system is the No. 1 challenge, and it’s an issue for the incumbent occasion as a result of a lot of voters don’t consider the economic system is doing properly in any respect. The explanation it’s an issue is obvious. Historical past reveals it by no means works to inform sad voters that they really stay in an exquisite economic system, and analysis reveals that people are hard-wired to consider what they really feel and never what another person tells them. Voters aren’t going to alter.
By the numbers, the U.S. economic system is probably not the best ever, however it actually isn’t unhealthy. Final 12 months it grew 2.2% adjusted for inflation, which is greater than most economists anticipated. The unemployment price stays low at 4.3%, and wages have grown, although not spectacularly.
That’s actuality, however what counts in politics is how voters really feel, and most don’t really feel contented. Shopper sentiment is about 20% under what it was when Trump was sworn in, in accordance with the College of Michigan’s long-running survey on that metric. Not everyone seems to be gloomy. “Sentiment surged for consumers with the largest stock portfolios,” says Michigan shopper survey director Joanne Hsu, however “it stagnated and remained at dismal levels” for the much more individuals with out shares.
That wasn’t a fluke. Researchers have discovered that we’ll pay twice as a lot to keep away from a foul end result as we’ll pay to obtain a very good end result that’s quantitively the identical. The opportunity of a foul end result looms bigger in our minds, which is why we keep in mind unhealthy outcomes longer. Final 12 months the costs of beef, dairy, espresso, footwear, clothes—fundamental wants—rose by double-digit percentages, and voters are prone to keep in mind that ache no matter the place costs go subsequent or how a lot GDP may enhance. Against this, think about how we really feel about prices of sure different fundamental wants for many individuals: gasoline and propane. These costs declined final 12 months. Ask your pals in the event that they knew that.
As a possible preview of this 12 months’s elections, think about President George H.W. Bush’s 1992 run for reelection. A quick, delicate recession had occurred in his time period and ended 19 months earlier than Election Day. When campaigning season arrived, he advised voters the economic system was booming, and he was appropriate. His opponent, Invoice Clinton, famously advised voters, “I feel your pain,” and he gained. He spoke to essentially the most highly effective a part of the human mind.
In fact, Trump isn’t on the poll this 12 months, and final 12 months there was no recession. A lot will occur earlier than Nov. 3. However expertise suggests a technique of telling voters the U.S. economic system is the best in historical past, when their hard-wired brains inform them in any other case, might be a tough highway to conserving management of Congress.
Be a part of us on the Fortune Office Innovation Summit Might 19–20, 2026, in Atlanta. The following period of office innovation is right here—and the outdated playbook is being rewritten. At this unique, high-energy occasion, the world’s most modern leaders will convene to discover how AI, humanity, and technique converge to redefine, once more, the way forward for work. Register now.
