A U.S. Justice Division lawyer informed jurors at a civil antitrust trial Tuesday that the live performance business is damaged as a result of Ticketmaster and its guardian Stay Nation Leisure have monopolized the market, driving up costs for shoppers, however the corporations say the federal government’s mistaken.
David Dahlquist, an legal professional with the Justice Division’s antitrust division, mentioned in his opening assertion that the US and 39 states are relying on the Manhattan federal jury to finish the monopoly and reward artists and shoppers with a aggressive market that may go away them with extra money.
“This case is about power, the power of a monopolist to control competition,” he mentioned. “Today, the concert ticket industry is broken.”
David Marriott, arguing on behalf of the businesses, disputed the federal government’s claims.
“We’ll let the numbers do the talking,” he mentioned. “We do not have monopoly power.”
Choose Arun Subramanian has informed jurors that proof might be introduced over the subsequent six weeks earlier than they’ll be left to resolve whether or not Stay Nation and Ticketmaster broke antitrust legal guidelines.
The trial stems from a lawsuit filed in 2024 that alleged the businesses have dominated the business by suffocating opponents and controlling every little thing from live performance promotion to ticketing.
Ticketmaster, which was established in 1976 and merged with Stay Nation in 2010, is the world’s largest ticket vendor throughout stay music, sports activities, theater and extra.
Dahlquist famous that the ticket vendor sparked outrage in November 2022 when its web site crashed throughout a presale occasion for a Taylor Swift stadium tour.
The corporate mentioned the location was overwhelmed by each followers and assaults from bots, which had been posing as shoppers to scoop up tickets and promote them on secondary websites. The debacle prompted congressional hearings and payments in state legislatures geared toward higher defending shoppers.
Dahlquist mentioned Stay Nation’s anti-competitive practices embrace utilizing long-term contracts starting from 5 to seven years to maintain venues from selecting rivals and blocking venues from utilizing a number of ticket sellers.
Ticketmaster’s clashes with artists and followers date again three many years. Pearl Jam took intention on the firm in 1994, years earlier than the Stay Nation merger, though the Justice Division finally declined to carry a case.
Stay Nation has maintained that artists and groups set costs and resolve how tickets are offered.
Marriott mentioned Stay Nation was the world’s largest supporter of musical artists, enabling 159 million folks in 2025 to see 11,000 artists at 55,000 concert events.
He mentioned the federal government has exaggerated how a lot the businesses make, together with by saying Ticketmaster pockets $7 a ticket, when it really will get $5 and clears lower than $2 after bills.
Stay Nation and Ticketmaster, he mentioned, “are all about bringing joy to people’s lives.”
