Fresnillo (LSE:FRES) has led the FTSE 100 larger within the final 12 months, however I’m staying nicely away in my very own portfolio. The inventory may climb additional, however it’s not one for me.
With gold and silver costs the place they’re, the corporate appears fantastically positioned for the close to future. However I don’t assume that’s a ok motive to think about shopping for the inventory as an investor.
Picture supply: Getty Pictures
Asset base
The primary factor that separates one mining firm from one other is the standard of its asset base. And there’s rather a lot to love about Fresnillo from this angle.
There are two important axes of analysis – value and reliability. On the primary level, the FTSE 100 firm’s vertical integration and scale offers it a value benefit over opponents.
On the second, having mines positioned in areas like Mexico, Peru, and Chile has traditionally been helpful. On the whole, these have been comparatively steady and supportive jurisdictions.
These are real strengths of Fresnillo that buyers are entitled to take very significantly. Realistically, although, they’re not the rationale the inventory has climbed 400% within the final 12 months.
Gold and silver costs
The primary motive the inventory has surged is that gold and silver costs have rocketed larger. Gold has gone from $2,981 per troy ounce to $4,999 and silver is up 145% since February 2025.
That has an outsize impact on mining earnings. If prices keep largely the identical, the extra income generated by larger costs drops straight by means of to the underside line as internet earnings.
The difficulty is, the reverse can also be true – if gold and silver costs fall, for no matter motive, the decrease costs instantly lower into margins in addition to gross sales. And that’s the chance proper now.
Are they going to? Forecasting commodity costs isn’t my speciality (and that in all probability should be sufficient by itself to maintain me on the sidelines) however I can see causes for warning.
What occurs subsequent?
There’s completely no assure costs are going to fall within the close to future. With silver, particularly, demand has outstripped provide over the previous couple of years and this appears set to proceed.
One motive for that is that silver is generally produced as a by-product of different metals. That makes it arduous for provide to regulate as miners additionally want to search out shops for different base metals.
The massive danger proper now, although, is the US greenback. Resilient inflation has led to hypothesis of upper rates of interest, fueled partly by the newest minutes from the US Federal Reserve.
That might be a giant drawback for silver and gold costs, that are denominated in {dollars}. So if fears a few weakening greenback trigger buyers to alter course, there might be an actual difficulty.
Incorrect time
The time to purchase shares in firms is when the market is underestimating them. However I feel it’s arduous to see that that is believable with Fresnillo proper now.
It’s no accident that gold and silver costs have surged lately. Nevertheless it’s additionally not clear that the forces which have propelled them larger are going to proceed over the long run.
In the event that they do, then Fresnillo shareholders stand to do very nicely. However with the inventory buying and selling the place it at present is, I feel the dangers imply I can discover higher alternatives elsewhere proper now.
